Talk:Newbie Tips: Difference between revisions

From Hattrick
Jump to navigationJump to search
← Older edit
Septimusjm (talk | contribs)
409 edits
redirect problem
Krake (talk | contribs)
52 edits
 
(12 intermediate revisions by 5 users not shown)
Line 1: Line 1:
How about this [[Newbie Tips]] page is simply redirected to [[:category:Newbie Tips]]? Then various articles can be created and given the "Newbie Tips" category tag. They'll show up on the main Newbie Tips Category page automatically. This leaves room for various takes on what a newbie actually needs to know/do. And you end up with a much less messy main page. (I already have the category page set-up if you want to take a look at it.) [[User:Septimusjm|Septimusjm]] 16:42, 30 November 2005 (UTC)
== New Tips Moved ==


----
We've moved Newbie Tips to a new [[:category:Newbie Tips|category page]]. For issues the redirect tag, see below.
As soon as it's affordable, change to a solid coach with poor leadership. This along with a good training regime should be the first priority for your team to succeed


----
Now it will be possible for various tips/tutorials to be created and given the Newbie Tips category tag. [[User:Septimusjm|Septimusjm]] 17:10, 30 November 2005 (UTC)


If however you can't afford a solid coach because of some newbie mistakes you've made you should at least consider hireling a passable coach


----
== redirect problem and solution ==


How about recommending them to take a look at the helping [[CHPP|programs]]?
For some reason if you redirect from this page to the [[:category:Newbie Tips]] page, the new page doesn't show the articles under the category "Newbie Tips." The solution we've come up with, for now, is to just provide a direct link to the category page, in which case everything works fine. NOTE: There is apparently no current solution to this problem except to provide a direct link to the category page. See this article [http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Wikipedia:Categorization#Redirected_categories]


----
=== redirect tag ===


Wikipedia has strict writing rules, and its articles are supposed to be presented from an objective, factual point of view. There are no official ones here, but I did take my time to reword this article and remove most subjective opinions and beliefs, as well as all the "you must" and "you should" orders. This is a wiki, a source of information, and not a dictatorship. Also, please read http://dictionary.reference.com/help/faq/language/i/ie-eg.html, note that football is a game (whereas two teams play a match), refrain from any specific names, and stop putting every other sentence in parenthesis. The structure is something I won't touch for now. -C2950
Please note the redirect tag DOES NOT work when redirecting to categories. There is a known wiki bug in this case. See link above for more information.


----
== further discussion ==


Very nice work! Just one question:
These "Ten principles" should probably be a category under "Newbie Tips." That way other types of newbie tips can also be added to this page.
 
quote: "(e.g. train one Primary skill for at least 3-4 seasons, and train 17-19yo players)"
 
I would say training 17yo players is most of the time not advisable, certainly not for newbies, and training players older than 19yo is highly underrated. Why shouldn't we advise newbies to calculate the expected profit per week of training and base their decision on that...?
 
----
 
This is a Wiki, dude - you're more than free to change the article :)




:That solution is probably better than what I see on the page now. Will revert. (think most will agree) --[[User:GM-Lau|GM-Lau]] 16:01, 22 December 2005 (UTC)


----
----
 
Thanks. I didn't read through all of what you reverted from, but it didn't look like a particulary good revision. :)  --[[User:Septimusjm|septimusjm]] 17:09, 22 December 2005 (UTC)
 
Dang...having problems getting the link to the category page for formations.
 
the principle #3 is missing.. hehe a secret key to success? :)
 
 
---
 
I've edited Pharbo's original tips back in, as they are appropriate here, I think the  opinion tag should be added though[[User:Dancing rob|Dancing rob]] 16:16, 29 November 2005 (UTC)
 
------
 
These "Ten principles" should probably be a category under "Newbie Tips." That way other types of newbie tips can also be added to this page.
 
== redirect problem ==
 
For some reason if you redirect from this page to the [[:category:Newbie Tips]] page, the new page doesn't show the artiles under the category "Newbie Tips." The solution we've come up with, for now, is to just provide a direct link to the category page, in which case everything works fine. [[User:Septimusjm|Septimusjm]] 16:59, 30 November 2005 (UTC)

Latest revision as of 12:05, 23 July 2007

New Tips Moved

We've moved Newbie Tips to a new category page. For issues the redirect tag, see below.

Now it will be possible for various tips/tutorials to be created and given the Newbie Tips category tag. Septimusjm 17:10, 30 November 2005 (UTC)


redirect problem and solution

For some reason if you redirect from this page to the category:Newbie Tips page, the new page doesn't show the articles under the category "Newbie Tips." The solution we've come up with, for now, is to just provide a direct link to the category page, in which case everything works fine. NOTE: There is apparently no current solution to this problem except to provide a direct link to the category page. See this article [1]

redirect tag

Please note the redirect tag DOES NOT work when redirecting to categories. There is a known wiki bug in this case. See link above for more information.

further discussion

These "Ten principles" should probably be a category under "Newbie Tips." That way other types of newbie tips can also be added to this page.


That solution is probably better than what I see on the page now. Will revert. (think most will agree) --GM-Lau 16:01, 22 December 2005 (UTC)

Thanks. I didn't read through all of what you reverted from, but it didn't look like a particulary good revision. :) --septimusjm 17:09, 22 December 2005 (UTC)

Retrieved from "https://wiki.hattrick.org/index.php?title=Talk:Newbie_Tips&oldid=67185"