HTs on Global/Long shot tactics

From Hattrick
Revision as of 14:26, 12 September 2008 by Mod-Karlthegreat (talk | contribs)
(diff) ← Older revision | Latest revision (diff) | Newer revision → (diff)
Jump to navigationJump to search
Keywords: (Long shots)
From: HT-Tjecken (11838895.1) as reply to (?)
To: Everyone 11.9.2008 at 10:18
Unfortunately we have to release some disappointing news today, which you can see on MyHT space now. As mentioned in the message we hate to do this, but releasing something which we don't think is 100% right feels utterly wrong. And we don't want to rush something new through...I think you agree in that. That said, I know you will not like these news that much. :(
Keywords: (Long shots), (Indirect free kicks)
From: HT-Tjecken (11838895.5) as reply to (11838895.3)
To: King-Mento 11.9.2008 at 10:22
What about indirect free kicks?

Still on.

Keywords: (Long shots)
From: HT-Tjecken (11838895.16) as reply to (11838895.8)
To: Karl-Heinz-Spock 11.9.2008 at 10:38
Can you tell what exactly is wrong with the way it was planned till now, and what direction you are heading now?

It's hard to say when it's more of a gut feeling, but I'll give it a try. We like the initial idea with how you have to convert the right chance, but in a way it kind of differs too much from the rest of the tactics. This makes it look complicated (even if it just looks far more complicated than what it really is), and that's not very much Hattrick. Moreover, it's also hard to spot the "downside" of this tactics, and we also think that can be a problem when users want to understand this tactic.

So, what we're aiming at is making it work a bit more like the other tactics, ie a design which is a little bit more simple.

Keywords: (Long shots)
From: HT-Tjecken (11838895.19) as reply to (11838895.10)
To: TomStar81 11.9.2008 at 10:42
Can you already give a guess when there will be a long shot tactic? Like in two seasons, in three or a "test" in friendlies already in the middle of next season?

I will not make any promise, but I hope it will be ready sooner than two-three seasons. And I think it will. After all, there are teams who have started to build their teams for long shots etc and we have an obligation to them that they haven't done that all in vain. So, it's safe to say that it will be a prioritized feature.

Keywords: (Long shots)
From: HT-Tjecken (11838895.23) as reply to (11838895.20)
To: Karl-Heinz-Spock 11.9.2008 at 10:48
And about the design of the tactic: I allways thought it should be somehow parallel to AiM and AoW, convert a percentage of chances, affect defence. Is that a direction you think of?

Yep we do, that's one possible direction for us.

Keywords: (Long shots)
From: HT-Tjecken (11838895.34) as reply to (11838895.27)
To: Karl-Heinz-Spock 11.9.2008 at 10:58
What are the other possible directions?

One could also think of kind of the CA conversion, which means there is no guarantee that a chance will be converted. (No extra chances are likely to be created, just to spell that out). There is also a defending team (as we got a defending sp rating to use), and that might also affect the conversion no matter which type of design you choose (making it not just up to the attacking team in that case).

Keywords: (Long shots)
From: HT-Tjecken (11838895.42) as reply to (11838895.33)
To: macao 11.9.2008 at 11:08
after all this mess don't you feel that the Long shot tactic even in the modified way you're thinking of, should become the immediate priority and introduced by next season anyway?

It is top priority for us, but we just don't want to make up a promise even though we think we will be ready within a season or so. First of all, we have to find a new design for long shots which we are satisfied with and which we're convinced will be a great addition to the game. And as we haven't done that yet (even if we got good hopes to find one), we feel it would be even more disrespectful to promise something which we frankly don't know if we will be able to live up to. I think it's already safe to say that we've failed to live up to some promises, and one lesson we have to learn from that is also that you can't promise on things which actually aren't ready yet. Especially not things which haven't left the drawing board yet, where long shots now are back on. This doesn't mean we don't hope or think it will be ready within a season or so, but we can't promise you that.

Keywords: (Long shots)
From: HT-Tjecken (11838895.57) as reply to (11838895.55)
To: papadoc 11.9.2008 at 11:52
This question interests me too. If I understood well, this was related to indirect free-kick reform, so it should change as announced. Is so, GK skill on free-kicks will integrate SP ability.

Yes. In short, all other "SP reforms" except long shots are still on.

Keywords: (Long shots)
From: HT-Tjecken (11838895.69) as reply to (11838895.66)
To: avelache 11.9.2008 at 13:19
Above you write that you've learned your lesson. Does this mean that from now on new features will be communicated in a later stadium?

Yes. In our aim to inform you as early as possible I think we took a bit too far. We will from now on inform when the feature is ready for (test)launch, and not when the feature has left the drawing board for implementation.